Pills, Potions, and Powders No More
In an article in last weeks' New York Times, Gina Kolata discusses the idea that athletes need special protein and carohydrate mixtures for optimal recovery. If you've been in endurance sports long, you've heard of the magic 4:1 ratio of carbohydrates to protein. It's true one needs carbohydrates and protein, but "as so often happens in sports, those grains of truth have been expanded into dictums and have formed the basis for an industry in 'recovery' products."
The bottom line of the article is that recovery products are not, as the marketing would have us believe, essential for performance. Furthermore, the article quotes Dr. Michael Rennie, a physiologist at the University of Nottingham, as saying at that 10 to 15 grams of protein per day is adequate for any adults. Bullocks, most people would say. It's true, though. As you eat enough calories from whole, plant foods, protein is a non-issue.
The article did use eggs and chicken as example of where to get that protein, which was too bad. Plants have protein too, along with carbohydrates, vitamins, minerals, fiber, phytonutrients, and essential fats. Animal products are seriously lacking in those areas.
- BradleySaul's blog
- Login or register to post comments






















Reading these things is like
Reading these things is like asking for aggravation!
It is very confusing. For example, i read what Phelps eats in a 'typical day', and it was about 12,000 calories over three meals, and much of it crap!! Pizza, etc..
I don't know if it was really very accurate, but there may be some truth to the idea that people can eat just about whatever they want... Would Phelps be *faster* eating whole foods? Or vegan whole foods? I dunno..i'd like to think so, but i don't know if there's much proof of it out there, eh?
I wonder if Chris Carmichael is helping to prove there 'is no magic ration' -- he claims that the ratio is 7:1, which seems to mesh more with what the article is suggesting (70g carbs, 15g protein).
I've wondered how much one really needs to consume after exercising. One consideration for me is that digestion takes a lot of energy, so eating something easy to digest is important..and less energy that is spent on digestion means (potentially) more energy spent on recovery..?